Licenses and the economics of openness
📍 Where we are: Part I · Roots — Chapter 2 of 16. Chapter 1 told how open printers appeared and how some narrowed their openness; this chapter explains the legal tools behind the word "open". It describes what the licence texts and OSHWA pages say; it is not legal advice.
Publishing a recipe does not by itself say what others may do with it. A licence is the note on the recipe card: "cook it, change it, sell the cake, but if you publish your changed recipe, share it the same way." Different notes exist for different things: one for the code, one for the circuit board, one for the photos and manuals. Using the wrong note, or a note with a hidden catch, is how a project ends up "open" in name only.
What this chapter covers
We compare licence families for code, hardware designs and documents, explain OSHWA certification, say why patents and trademarks sit outside most licences, sketch how open-hardware businesses operate, and show what "open-washing" looks like.
Three kinds of thing, three kinds of licence
A printer project contains software, hardware designs, and documents. Licensing them separately is exactly what OSHWA recommends [11].
Code
- GPL-3.0 is a copyleft licence: if you pass on a work based on the program, the whole work must be licensed under the same licence to anyone who receives it (section 5); contributors also grant a patent licence for their essential patent claims (section 11) [1]. Marlin, Klipper and RepRapFirmware use it (Chapter 4).
- MIT is a short permissive licence. Its only condition is that the copyright and permission notices travel with the software; it disclaims warranty [2].
- Apache-2.0 is permissive too but contains an explicit patent grant from each contributor, which ends for you if you start a patent suit over the work [3].
OSHWA says all software needed to run certified hardware must use an OSI-approved licence, and recommends Apache, GPL, LGPL, MIT and Mozilla [12].
Hardware designs
Hardware is harder. OSHWA's own guidance says copyright often covers only some elements of a physical design because "the creativity is often constrained by functionality", and that licences demanding shared contributions "may not be legally enforceable". It still advises licensing, as "guiding tools for good actors" [11]. The licences OSHWA suggests are:
| Licence | Style | Notes from the texts |
|---|---|---|
| CERN-OHL-P-2.0 | Permissive | Patent licence in section 6; bars use of the licensor's or CERN's name to suggest endorsement (section 7.2) [5] |
| CERN-OHL-W-2.0 | Weakly reciprocal | Defines "External Material" as material combined with the covered source only through a documented interface [20] |
| CERN-OHL-S-2.0 | Strongly reciprocal | Modified Covered Source must be conveyed under the same licence; products must come with the complete source or a pointer to it; patent licence in section 7 [4] |
| TAPR OHL v1.0 | Reciprocal | Written for physical things and their documentation, not for software; leans on patent-related terms [7] |
CERN lists the three variants on its licence page [6]. OSHWA likens P, S and W to Apache, GPL3 and LGPL3 respectively [11]. If a CERN-OHL v2 notice names no variant, the source is treated as CERN-OHL-S [4].
Documents, photos and artwork
Creative Commons (CC) licences suit manuals and images. Creative Commons itself recommends against using them for software and does not recommend them for hardware; its licences "do not license trademark or patent rights" [8]. The exception it names is CC0, described as GPL-compatible and acceptable for software. Prusa's own firmware repository applies CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 to "graphics and design" (Chapter 3); OSHWA does not accept non-commercial clauses for certified software [12].
What "open-source hardware" means: the OSHWA definition
The OSHW Definition 1.0 lists criteria including documentation in the "preferred format for making changes", permission to make derived works and to make and sell products from the design, free redistribution, no discrimination against persons or fields of endeavour, and technology neutrality [9].
Certification
OSHWA runs a certification programme. Creators self-certify through an online form, everything under their control must be open, third-party chips need datasheets that are accessible and shareable, and each unique product receives a UID (a two-letter country code plus six digits, for example US000001) [10] [13]. Registration is free and per project [13]. The certification mark is itself governed by usage guidelines [10].
Patents and trademarks
Patents and trademarks sit outside most of the licences above. OSHWA's FAQ says patents are compatible with open-source hardware if you license them in a way that complies with the definition, and that many creators skip patents altogether [13]. CERN-OHL-P bars using the licensor's name to suggest endorsement [5], and Creative Commons says its licences do not license trademark rights [8].
The economics of openness
We did not find a systematic, sourced study of business models for open 3D-printer hardware, so the following are patterns visible in the sources, not a ranking.
- Maintain the firmware as a company. Duet3D maintains RepRapFirmware under GPLv3 [18]; we did not verify the licence of its boards.
- Ship open code in products. Marlin's README tells vendors who ship it that they must keep it open and supply the source on request [17].
- Community-run designs. The Voron 2.4 repository is GPL-3.0 [19].
Open-washing
"Open-washing" means using the word "open" for something that does not meet the usual definitions. A live example is Prusa's Open Community License (OCL). Prusa's 19 December 2025 post says OCL users may study and modify the CORE One files, share changes under the OCL and use them in their own business, but not "sell complete machines or remixes based on these files" without a separate agreement; the post contrasts OCL with OSI licences, which it calls the gold standard for collaboration [14]. The OCL repository describes commercial users as limited to internal business use [15].
Read side by side, the OSHW definition requires a licence that allows making, selling, distributing and using products built from the design [9], whereas the OCL does not allow selling machines built from the files. On that reading the OCL does not meet the definition; whether it is "open source" in a legal sense is a question for lawyers and we do not decide it. A community complaint (Issue #13, June 2026) argues that Prusa's wording was misleading, and was still open in November 2026 with no Prusa reply in the thread [16].
Code, hardware and documents each have their own licence families; trademarks and patents are outside most licences, and OSHWA certification is a mark layered on top.
Original diagram by the authors, created with AI assistance.
Why it matters
The licence decides whether you can build, sell, repair or fork a machine. Checking it takes minutes and prevents surprises.
In the real world
Before reusing a design, read the repository's licence file, any OSHWA certification entry and any trademark policy. For commercial use, ask a lawyer.
Key terms
- Copyleft — a licensing approach that requires modified versions to be shared under the same licence.
- Permissive licence — a licence, such as MIT or Apache-2.0, that allows reuse with few conditions beyond attribution.
- CERN-OHL — the CERN Open Hardware Licence, version 2 (2020), in permissive (P), weakly reciprocal (W) and strongly reciprocal (S) variants.
- TAPR OHL — an older open hardware licence from the amateur radio community, for physical designs rather than software.
- Creative Commons (CC) — a family of licences for creative works such as documents and images; they do not license patents or trademarks.
- OSHWA — the Open Source Hardware Association, which maintains the OSHW definition and a certification programme.
- OSHWA certification — a per-project registration with a mark and a UID, requiring the creator's own contributions to be open.
- Open-washing — using "open" for something that does not meet the commonly accepted definition.
Where this leads
With the history and the legal groundwork in place, we can open the machine itself in anatomy of an open printer.